Mud Pies April Fool’s #SundaySupper

Spring means muddy season around here. The ground thaws out. Snow melts. Creeks rise. So why not make Mud Pies?
Mud Pie
Moist, dark, clumps packed into individual pie shells. You know, getting back to nature.
I love getting dirty. Prepping the garden. Digging my hands in the soil and squishing it through my fingers.
It kind of like cooking. Now wait, hear me out.
I cook by feel as much as sight, smell, sound and taste. Listen for the sizzle or flop of dough on the hook. Potatoes squeak when roasted. Have you ever ran to the stove because you heard a pot boil over?
Dough needs (no pun intended) to reach a certain texture. You knead it until it feels right.
Meatloaf gets mixed by hand. Its ready when it holds together but still feels moist.
I was stumped when the April Fool’s Day Sunday Supper theme was announced. Then I looked outside. It just rained and there was mud everywhere.


If you haven’t already guessed it, this muddy mess is really tasty cake, pudding and chocolate cookie crumbs.

Its more a method than a recipe. Fun dessert or treat!
First, take a 9-inch pie crust, homemade or purchased and cut it into 4 pieces. Press each piece into a large muffin tin cup. Don’t worry, it doesn’t need to be perfect, its mud pie!
mud pie dough

Bake for about 9 minutes at 350, no grease until almost baked. Remove and set aside. Residual heat should finish the baking. If not, return to the oven. Let completely cool before removing from tin.
mud pie crustRemove the cream filling. Crumble the cookies. What you do with the creamy centers is your business. 😉

Fill with cake, pudding and cookie mix. Decorate with cookie crumbs.

mud pies (550x550)


Mud Pies April Fool’s

Yield: 8 cakes


  • 2 9-inch pie crusts
  • 1 8-inch chocolate cake (one layer)
  • 1 cup chocolate pudding
  • 10 chocolate sandwich cookies plus 2 for garnish (I used Oreos) cream removed and crushed


  • Cut the crusts into 4 pieces each. Press each piece into a large muffin tin cup. Prick with a fork. Bake at 450 for about 9 minutes or until almost done. Remove and place pan on rack. Dough should finish cooking outside oven. Return to oven if needed. Cool completely before removing.
  • Mix together cake crumbs, pudding and cookie crumbs.
  • Fill pie shells. Garnish with additional crumbs. Serve with whipped cream if desired.
Schema/Recipe SEO Data Markup by Yummly Rich Recipes

mud pie plate

Thanks  T.R. of Gluten Free Crumbley for hosting this fun event!


April 1st is just around the corner. Get ready with these Foolproof Recipes from Sunday Supper!



Sides & Snacks



Sunday Supper MovementJoin the #SundaySupper conversation on twitter on Sunday! We tweet throughout the day and share recipes from all over the world. Our weekly chat starts at 7:00 pm ET. Follow the #SundaySupper hashtag and remember to include it in your tweets to join in the chat. To get more great Sunday Supper Recipes, visit our website or check out our Pinterest board.

Would you like to join the Sunday Supper Movement? It’s easy. You can sign up by clicking here: Sunday Supper Movement.

This entry was posted in #SundaySupper, cake, chocolate, dessert, pie, What's For Dinner? and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

27 Responses to Mud Pies April Fool’s #SundaySupper

  1. Pingback: Sneaky Veggie Spaghetti Sauce #SundaySupper | Small Wallet Big Appetite

  2. Pingback: Super green muffins #SundaySupper - Caroline's Cooking

  3. Pingback: Potluck Chili Cupcakes for #Sunday Supper | A Palatable Pastime

  4. Laura says:

    These look so tasty
    Laura recently posted..Sneaky Veggie Spaghetti Sauce #SundaySupperMy Profile

  5. Liz says:

    Now this is the kind of mud I’d have no trouble eating! Perfect for April Fools Day!!!
    Liz recently posted..Strawberry Fool #SundaySupperMy Profile

  6. Pingback: Fake-Out Sliders and Fries by The Redhead Baker

  7. Pingback: Fudgy Granola Bars | Pies and Plots

  8. Pingback: Middle Eastern Chicken with Green Harissa #SundaySupper | The Texan New Yorker

  9. Pingback: Bacon and "Eggs" Cupcakes #SundaySupper - Hezzi-D's Books and Cooks

  10. Sue Lau says:

    One of my favorite posts for Sunday Supper this week. Cute!
    Sue Lau recently posted..Potluck Chili Cupcakes for #Sunday SupperMy Profile

  11. Pingback: {Recipe} Shepherd's Trifle for #SundaySupper - The Joyful Foodie

  12. This looks so yummy and sounds really fun to put together!
    Laura Dembowski recently posted..Fudgy Granola Bars #SundaySupperMy Profile

  13. Shaina says:

    These are TOO cute!! And those little shovels as the spoon? Genius!
    Shaina recently posted..Boca Restaurant Review: Zinburger Wine & Burger BarMy Profile

  14. Hezzi-D says:

    Those mini shovels are too cute! I love these mud pies…and I’m sure my kids at school woudl too!
    Hezzi-D recently posted..Bacon and “Eggs” Cupcakes #SundaySupperMy Profile

  15. You kind of had me with your beautiful little crust! This looks wonderful!!! YUM!
    Valerie Cathell Clark recently posted..Berry Smoothie Incognito for #SundaySupper April FoolsMy Profile

  16. Sarah says:

    Absolutely delish – I would kill for this as a kid
    Sarah recently posted..Chocolate Cauliflower Cake – April Fools #SundaySupperMy Profile

  17. I’m such a sucker for mud pie. You styled these so well (those little shovels!) that I did a double take to see if they weren’t really soil. 😛
    Joy | The Joyful Foodie recently posted..{Recipe} Shepherd’s Trifle for #SundaySupperMy Profile

  18. These are so cute! But, they look so realistic, I might be a bit hesitant biting into one!
    Sarah | Curious Cuisiniere recently posted..Hot Cross BunsMy Profile

  19. Pingback: #SundaySupper: April Fool’s | Sew You Think You Can Cook

  20. That little spade/shovel is adorable! Fun recipe.
    Lauren @ Sew You Think You Can Cook recently posted..#SundaySupper: Easter/Passover LeftoversMy Profile

Comments are closed.